swii.ch Logo
Rare disease patient insight & strategy
Get in touch
swii.ch Logo
Rare disease patient insight & engagement 
Get in touch

Exploring the Effectiveness of Lay Summaries: Collaborating with Patients for Clarity and Empowerment.

Back to posts

In the modern healthcare landscape, where the language of medicine can be overwhelming, the quest for clear and concise information is paramount. Lay summaries have emerged as a potential solution, aiming to bridge the gap between complex medical information and the general public. However, as we delve into their effectiveness, it becomes evident that the journey to clarity requires collaborative efforts with patients, caregivers, and advocacy groups.

The Need for Clarity: Lay Summaries in Focus

Lay summaries have been hailed as a vital tool for making medical research accessible to the broader public. These summaries, distilled versions of complex research findings, are intended to break down barriers of jargon and technicality.

They aim to empower patients, caregivers, and the public by presenting information in plain language. Yet, the question arises: are current lay summaries truly effective in achieving their objectives?

Research Reveals Gaps: Insights from "Trial Lay Summaries Were Not Fit for Purpose"

A study by Frances Shiely and Anna Daly, titled "Trial Lay Summaries Were Not Fit for Purpose" and published in the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology (Vol. 156, 2023), casts a spotlight on this issue. The study employed the SMOG readability scale, designed for assessing healthcare material, to gauge the readability of a random sample of 60 lay summaries.

The results were eye-opening: more than 85% of these summaries were difficult to read, and none were categorized as easy to read. This research underscores the reality that achieving effective communication requires more than just simplifying language.

The Missing Piece: Collaborating with Patients, Caregivers, and Advocacy Groups

One of the critical revelations from the study is the importance of co-creation. Patients, caregivers, and advocacy groups possess insights that go beyond mere words. They understand the nuances of living with a condition, the emotional aspects, and the questions that matter most.

Collaborating with these stakeholders in crafting lay summaries can transform them from sterile documents into meaningful tools for understanding and empowerment.

Recommendations for Empowerment: Learning from Research

The study by Shiely and Daly doesn't merely point out gaps; it also offers recommendations for improvement. One crucial step is to involve participants with a variety of experiences. This includes individual patients with personal disease experiences, patients knowledgeable in trial methodology, patient advocates who understand community perspectives, and members of the public with no trial exposure. Such diversity ensures that the summaries resonate across different backgrounds and perspectives.

Empowering the Future: Charting a Path Forward

The journey toward effective lay summaries is ongoing. It necessitates a collaborative mindset that respects the insights and needs of patients, caregivers, and advocacy groups. By tapping into patient language, understanding cultural nuances, and testing and validating summaries with the intended audience, healthcare communication can be transformed.

The road to empowerment lies in acknowledging that patients aren't just passive recipients of information; they are active partners in their healthcare journey.

In conclusion, while the effectiveness of lay summaries may vary, their potential for empowerment is undeniable. The study's findings underscore the importance of moving beyond simplification and embracing patient-centered collaboration.

As we work towards a future where healthcare information is clear, accessible, and resonant, the role of patients and advocacy groups as architects of understanding cannot be overstated.


  • Shiely, F., & Daly, A. (2023). Trial Lay Summaries Were Not Fit for Purpose. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 156, 105-112.
swii.ch Logo
Rare disease patient insight & engagement
© swii.ch Health 2024.
Privacy Policy
We use cookies in order to give you the best possible experience on our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.